We're hiring

We love digital - Call
03332 207 677
and say hello - Mon - Fri, 9am - 5pm

Call 03332 207 677

James Perrin

SEO Horror Stories and Nightmares

31st Oct 2011 News, Industry News 3 minutes to read

GhostsWe all know a good horror story or two, we all have our favourite scary movies, but nothing comes close to the SEO and digital marketing nightmares that have taken place this year. In the spirit of Halloween we thought why not share a couple of horror stories of our own; a lot has happened this year and these are just some of the tales that’ll be enough to make anyone in the industry shudder in fear.

JC Penney

It’s February and many online retailers are feeling the post Christmas blues but for JC Penney the whole situation was going to get a lot worse. Their site was ranking extremely well, a little too well, in fact their site was ranking so well they were even outranking the original manufactures site’s for their own products, such as Samsonite suitcases. After an investigation by the New York Times, in which they hired an SEO specialist to look at the matter, it turned out they were buying links to appear in completely unrelated websites, with the links well hidden to ‘game the system’ [See: Looking for a Black Hat? Good luck finding one at JC Penney].

Google’s Matt Cutts who’s the head of Web Spam at the search giant confirmed that this was in violation of their Webmaster guidelines and took prompt action again JC Penney, who now are only just slowing gaining their way back up the rankings as a result. What’s scary isn’t just the fact that anyone can fall foul of the search lord, even huge retailers such as JC Penney, but if you do choose an SEO agency to manage your campaigns, make sure you know exactly what they’re doing, otherwise it’ll go down as another SEO horror story.

Brian Souter

More recently we had the Brian Souter story; this is a really scary one as Brian hadn’t appeared to be flouting any of the search engine rules [See: Why Has Brian Souter Fallen Off Google?]. Brian took umbrage at the fact his site was completely stripped of its rankings, seemingly out of nowhere. His site was fairly well optimised, it had around 50 links and all Meta was optimised, so what happened?

Where this story gets really horrifying is that unlike the JC Penney case, it appeared that Google’s algorithm had picked up a problem as opposed to Google having to dish out a manual penalty. Also unlike the JC Penney case, this wasn’t as black and white to establish what the cause was, unless we fully understand the meticulous workings of Google’s algorithm. What this does point to is a possible negative publicity filter. You see Brian Souter carries with him a fare bit of controversy and as a result there is a bit of negative press out there. Whilst this does show that Google’s algorithm is becoming more sophisticated it is really only one reason why Brian Souter fell off Google, other than that, it’s a mystery.

DecorMyEyes (Last year I know, but still a good story nonetheless)

The negative publicity filter may have come about as a result of the DecorMyEyes case. The owner of said website, Vitaly Borker, horrifically ranted and harassed any customer that complained about his service online [See: I’d Do Anything for a Link…But I Won’t do that!]. He was using negativity to his advantage because the more people complained the more links he would receive. This is pretty scary in itself, but this particular SEO horror story actually has a happy ending. The algorithmic change has meant that people like Vitaly won’t be able to take advantage of negative PR or press.

So there we have it, three SEO horror stories, but there are still many more out there. Panda anyone? That was a horror story for most people in the industry. Not only that, but across the digital marketing landscape there have been many changes to the industry which are frightening for all of us. For example the EU cookie directive [See: E-Privacy Directive on Cookies] or Google’s move to SSL [See: Video Guide to the Google SSL Changes and Hidden Keyword Data]. If you can think of anymore, please share your SEO horror stories below.

Image Source

Ghost cake pops via BigStock

Share this post


What do you think?

  • aspect-ratio google-adwords-analytics-attribution
    Conor Maurice

    Attribution 101: Google Analytics and AdWords

    In today’s multichannel world, there are mountains of data which provide insights into how users have interacted with your business and their path to conversion (or non-conversion). It is important to understand performance with multichannel marketing, which can be achieved through attribution modelling. Attribution refers to assigning credit to something (a channel, touchpoint, etc.) for the role it played in the final conversion. An attribution model is a rule, or set of rules, that assigns this credit correctly to the right channel or touchpoint.


    Conor Maurice
    26th Mar 2018
  • aspect-ratio bing-logo-woodsign
    Liam Huckins

    Why Bing is a Valuable Paid Media Platform

    For a long time, Bing, the UK’s second-largest search engine, has been underappreciated and, in some instances, even ignored.  Often regarded as the inferior search engine to market leader Google, Bing has historically struggled to appeal to many in the digital world. Most PPC analysts would give justified reasons for neglecting Bing for so long; these include the volume of traffic and the user experience just not matching up to Google. However, the validity of these assessments is now diminishing. Bing has grown and improved rapidly in the last couple of years; if you are not integrating it into your comprehensive digital marketing plan, you run the risk of missing out on a large portion of your chosen market and significant revenue.


    Liam Huckins
    8th Mar 2018
    Paid Search

Digital Ideas Monthly

Sign up now and get our free monthly email. It’s filled with our favourite pieces of the news from the industry, SEO, PPC, Social Media and more. And, don’t forget - it’s free, so why haven’t you signed up already?