We're hiring

We love digital - Call
03332 207 677
and say hello - Mon - Fri, 9am - 5pm

Call 03332 207 677

Stephen Logan

Is Online Censorship a Good Thing?

11th Oct 2011 News, Industry News 3 minutes to read

Censorship is a subject that always divides opinions. Some see it as a protective barrier between the general public and indecency, others as a form of unnecessary outside intervention.

When Google deliberately flouted censorship rules in China, they were promptly booted out of the country. Australia has been slowly moving towards ratifying a policy to prevent its citizens from viewing particular content, most notably adult material – although this hasn’t proved popular with all, including the US. Now it appears that the UK might be next to follow suit, albeit with the option to opt-in.

Whilst oppressive regimes go to extraordinary lengths to prevent ‘dangerous’ or ‘subversive’ content from being shown (i.e. news about oppression), democratic societies have largely steered clear of any such intervention. The current proposal – and it is only a proposal at this stage – here in Britain though would see broadband providers offering customers the opportunity to opt-out (or opt-in, depending on which report you read) from accessing pornography.

There are some would still call this censorship, it is a very diluted form. The saving grace for many is that it isn’t going to be state-led and will therefore fall under the jurisdiction of Internet providers. Equally, customers will only be asked once (when setting up the account) and have the choice to opt-in or not. Presumably they will also then have the option to change their mind if they wish later on too.

So what’s the problem?

Even watered down censorship contains that most loaded and emotive word. There are so many controls that you can apply yourself, including parental locks on Internet browsers, that many deem it unnecessary to apply any form of external filter.  The Internet was developed as a free resource, so why are we looking to cut out specific content?

As with the Australian proposition, the big issue appears to be the ready availability of pornography that is now available online and the effect this has on children. It’s certainly difficult to argue with the dangers of this and other explicit content. So why would anyone want to keep this kind of material and ensure that it remains accessible to all?

Well, it’s a freedom of choice issue. Whilst those defending the right to access may have no desire to actually see the content on a personal level, they believe that others should have the choice. However, as previously mentioned, where this particular issue isn’t being passed down as government legislation or strictly enforced, the impact and reaction to it is likely to be more muted.

However, some may worry that this could set a precedent. Due to the furore that censorship has caused elsewhere and the coverage that any attempts to apply filters have already had, it is unlikely that any such universal will be made that curtails access – particularly now that the Internet is perceived as a human right by the UN. However, educating people on effective self-censorship might well provide the best solution.

As adults, we can make the decision about what we choose to view. However, we can also ensure that any children or impressionable users are kept away from anything that could be deemed inappropriate. Internet providers, browsers and even operating systems provide numerous layers of control to allow you to limit accessibility. By increasing awareness of these controls and how to use them, we can take responsibility and prevent (or at least make it very difficult) for children to access adult material.

Any censorship over and above this could certainly create a backlash. Illegal material should be targeted and removed, as it is currently, whilst everything else should remain in the public domain. Broadband level opt-in is somewhere in the middle, hence the kerfuffle, but certainly isn’t something to be overly concerned about.

But whether you think censorship is needed or not will be entirely down to personal opinion. And there are certainly plenty of people with big opinions on the matter. Feel free to leave yours in the box below.

Share this post

What do you think?

  • aspect-ratio google-adwords-analytics-attribution
    Conor Maurice

    Attribution 101: Google Analytics and AdWords

    In today’s multichannel world, there are mountains of data which provide insights into how users have interacted with your business and their path to conversion (or non-conversion). It is important to understand performance with multichannel marketing, which can be achieved through attribution modelling. Attribution refers to assigning credit to something (a channel, touchpoint, etc.) for the role it played in the final conversion. An attribution model is a rule, or set of rules, that assigns this credit correctly to the right channel or touchpoint.

    (more…)

    Conor Maurice
    26th Mar 2018
    Analytics
  • aspect-ratio bing-logo-woodsign
    Liam Huckins

    Why Bing is a Valuable Paid Media Platform

    For a long time, Bing, the UK’s second-largest search engine, has been underappreciated and, in some instances, even ignored.  Often regarded as the inferior search engine to market leader Google, Bing has historically struggled to appeal to many in the digital world. Most PPC analysts would give justified reasons for neglecting Bing for so long; these include the volume of traffic and the user experience just not matching up to Google. However, the validity of these assessments is now diminishing. Bing has grown and improved rapidly in the last couple of years; if you are not integrating it into your comprehensive digital marketing plan, you run the risk of missing out on a large portion of your chosen market and significant revenue.

    (more…)

    Liam Huckins
    8th Mar 2018
    Paid Search

Digital Ideas Monthly

Sign up now and get our free monthly email. It’s filled with our favourite pieces of the news from the industry, SEO, PPC, Social Media and more. And, don’t forget - it’s free, so why haven’t you signed up already?