We're hiring

We love digital - Call
03332 207 677
and say hello - Mon - Fri, 9am - 5pm

Call 03332 207 677

Stephen Logan

Have Google SERPs Become Too Complicated?

3rd Dec 2010 News, Industry News 3 minutes to read

Even as somebody who works with the Internet day in, day out, the near complete overhaul in Google’s results pages this year has taken me aback slightly. First there was social integration, then we (briefly) lost the UK searches button, next up was site search, before Google Instant came along and blew everything out of the water.

Your average SERP has changed immeasurably. Not just in terms of aesthetics or even function, but in its very make-up. The way sites are being ranked and what results are returned is a world away from what we had last year.

Let’s take the massive brand push as a good example. 12 months ago it would be unthinkable that a single site could dominate a Google result page. Now you can routinely find major brands securing the top four or five positions – sometimes even more [see: Big Brands Benefit from Latest Google Update].

Of course, it would be impossible to talk about changes to Google SERPs without at least mentioning the Places update [What Does the Google Places SERP Update Mean for Local Search?]. Overnight the whole makeup of result pages changed. Local searches were now embedded within general queries, with company info and even a map for support. Suddenly organic rankings were overhauled and local optimisation became paramount.

Google Instant and the various updates associated with its inclusion (such as the site preview function) hasn’t massively influenced the way the SERPs look or act; however, it has impacted the way we search. By automatically updating as you type, a searcher can charge through numerous results pages whilst performing a single search. It also allows you to browse without using a map, by including a blue navigational arrow which tabs through the results on request [see: Google SERP Browsing Goes Mouse-Free].

Along with all the on page elements – such as news, images and video – the Google results are almost unrecognisable. If I had been marooned on a desert island for the past year or so, search would be an alien concept. So much has happened, so much has been added, it sometimes seems like the only thing that hasn’t changed is the logo.

The same feeling of confusion must be true for occasional users too. When I discuss it with non-Internet folk (i.e. all my friends and family), there is a sense of bemusement as to what it all means. Most appear to just ignore the majority of added elements and dive in for the result that best matches their expectations. Complete obliviousness is not uncommon.

So does Google really need to be continually adding elements and complication to its SERPs? Is it helping your search experience?

Naturally I search with monotonous regularity, so I’m increasingly blind to everything. Instant is switched off and I rarely browse, it’s one product or piece of information that I’m after – the rest is superfluous. Whilst I recognise why Google is evolving, it could be seen as just adding more clutter in the way of what would ordinarily be a linear journey. There’s a fair chance that I’m not alone in this too.

The issue is that on any given day you can get a Google SERP that includes any combination of:

  • Organic results
  • Paid adverts
  • Local ‘Places’ results
  • Social
  • News
  • Video
  • Image
  • Shopping
  • And Related Searches

It’s a mess of information. But as long as you know what you’re looking for, the rest is easily ignored. Unfortunately, for those who are trying to get ahead on search engines through SEO, each element adds an extra obstacle (as well as a potential opportunity of course). Equally, if you’re entirely clueless as to what it is that you want to find, then confusion could point you in the direction of something not entirely relevant.

So what do you think, have Google’s SERPs become too complicated? Or are Google simply innovators trying to offer the best service? We know that you have to evolve or die online, but have they gone too far now? What do you think might be next too?

Share this post

What do you think?

  • aspect-ratio site-speed-blog
    Ross Momtahan

    A Guide To Page Speed Metrics

    Site speed is an important area of website optimisation that people working in the world of Search Engine Optimisation are becoming increasingly concerned about.

    With Google’s site speed update being rolled out to all users on July 9th, now is the time to audit your site speed if you haven’t done it for a while. (more…)

    Ross Momtahan
    20th Jul 2018
    SEO
  • aspect-ratio
    Dan Rice

    What Does Content Marketing Mean?

    The term “content marketing” is frequently thrown around by marketers, influencers and business owners, but what does it actually mean? Let’s kick off with a quick definition before we take a closer look at this concept.

    (more…)

    Dan Rice
    @thedangrice
    18th Jul 2018
    Content Marketing

Digital Ideas Monthly

Sign up now and get our free monthly email. It’s filled with our favourite pieces of the news from the industry, SEO, PPC, Social Media and more. And, don’t forget - it’s free, so why haven’t you signed up already?
  • We’ve got some really cool stuff we want to share with you. So you don’t miss out, let us know which of the following you want us to email you about going forward:
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.